Order Toll Free 1-877-339-5855
News, How-tos, and assorted Views on Accordance Bible Software.

Thursday, February 07, 2008  

Buried Comments on Blogs

In contrast to the inflammatory exchanges on some of the news sites which I frequent, the comments on our blog posts are usually pretty tame (for which I am thankful). However, I am surprised when people comment on really old blog posts (yesterday it was an 18 months old post) as if anyone is likely to see or care about the comment. This is OK on the Forum, but not a good idea on the Blog.

Here's the difference: on the Forum when you add a reply to a topic, that topic jumps to the top of the list in that forum, as well as appearing in Today's Posts and New Posts. Thus anyone browsing the Forums is likely at least to scan the title and be aware of your reply.

The Blog, in contrast, is strictly linear. While you can search it for keywords, you cannot look for new comments. Only David and I are notified of each comment posted (and we do try to reply where necessary). Thus the comments to older posts are essentially buried, and there is not a lot of point in adding to them, or continuing a discussion on any post over a month old.

The other advantage to the Forum is that any member can start a new topic, whereas this Blog is more personal, and mainly written by David (when he has time). ;-)

I hope this helps to explain the difference between these sections of our website. Your comments are welcome on both....

In general, I agree. But I still see an advantage to leaving comments on old blog posts -- the comments can be seen if someone does a web search and the blog post comes up in the results.

Sure, you're not going to get as much continued discussion on an 18-month old blog entry. But you still might be able to contribute something that will be useful to a future web-searcher. Who knows? Perhaps the reason you're commenting on that blog post is because you got there via a web search yourself....

It is also advantageous in that if it was a blog that generated a lot of discusison, previous commentors may have asked blogger to notify them of follow-up comments

I agree on both counts. I often find old blog posts whilst searching, and on more than one occasion have found a courteously left comment bringing me up to speed where the content of the post itself is out of date. People will comment in context of the issue at hand, it makes more sense that way. Blog owners can always repost and link within the old post if the comments turn up anything that significant. And of course, as Danny says, there are those who keep tracks. Keep the comments coming!

Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?