Jump to content

Is there a way to search for second perfect participles


Jonna Schmidt

Recommended Posts

I am studying BBG with Dr. Mounce, and he mentions in his book (Section 30.17) that there are six verbs that use the second perfects. 

 

How can I do a search and get his results which include:

 

a. John 18.21: ακουω

 

b. John 1:51:   ανοιγω

 

c. Matt 25:24:  ειληφως

 

δ. πεποιθως, οτος΄εληλυθως, οτος, γεγονως, οτος

 

Thanks

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We are no longer distinguishing second perfects or second aorists. This is Dr. Koivisto's explanation of the issue:

 

 

We have made the decision to remove and discontinue using 2Aorist and 2Perfect tags for the following reasons:
    • These tags were misleading many users into thinking that all our Greek texts could be searched to find these tags. They could not. They were originally designed for our premier GNT products and only partially implemented in other tagged texts that were developed in more recent years. In the tagged texts we licensed from other developers, they were not implemented at all. Search results that were done on other tagged texts were therefore not complete and misleading and/or puzzling our users.
    • The 2Aorist tags that were used in the premier GNT tagged texts were disputed. The problem is a lack of consensus among scholars in terms of defining a 2Aorist. Does one go by internal stem differentiation from the present stem? Or does one go by the endings? And what about those instances where you have a 2Aorist stem (EIPON) but 1Aorist endings (EIPA)?
    • In addition, the reality is  that there is no semantic difference between 1Aorist and 2Aorist, or between Perfect and 2Perfect. An Aorist is an Aorist, and a Perfect is a Perfect. There are simply two different ways of constructing such forms.
    • It was concluded that those interested in searching for only 2Aorist or 2Perfect were primarily teachers looking for didactic reasons to show their students a list of these for their reference. They have no real value in interpreting the text itself. Such refined morphological distinctions hold very little, if any, value for the scholar, pastor, and GNT student exegeting the text.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

So, it is no longer possible to search directly for the tag 2Perfect.

 

There may be found in a different way, though.

 
You may search for inflected forms that contain -k-:
 
'*k?*' @ [Verb perfect act]
 
This will find the 1Perfects, as they include a -k- as part of the 1 perfect stem.
 
If you negate the '*k?*' part, you should find the 2Perfects:
 
[Verb perfect act] @-'*k?*' 
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I realize that the search doesn't find ακηκοα, as it has two -k-

So, user beware.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...