Jump to content


Photo

Adding just one, which WBC volume do You suggest that has f.e. a Catholic or an Anglican author?


  • Please log in to reply
5 replies to this topic

#1 Unix

Unix

    Gold

  • Active Members
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 205 posts
  • Twitter:mcyklist
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:inter/multidisciplinary humanities
  • Interests:Hebrew, "Gnosticism", Anglican books, (Environmental and a bit of Ethnological) History as well as that I've recently renewed interest in Architectual History and more modern Cultural History /Aug. 2. 2017, particular interest in texts copyrighted 1952-2010, Autumn '16 Greek. christianforums.com, unorthodoxchristian.freeforums.net Purchased Scrivener as both Win and Mac versions early June and a used Macbook Pro June 13., HDDRegenerator.net on July 17. 2015. Yet to install my Accordance version upgrade to 12 , I've been satisfied with the availability of modules in the v.10 resource format - I have just one maintained version 10 installation - it's on the i3 quad core Dell laptop. /Aug. 2. 2017
  • Accordance Version:10.x
  • Platforms:Windows

Posted 21 November 2017 - 02:17 PM

Right now I'm putting so much money into a nice piece of furniture and have been buying printed matter, that I can only afford one volume.
I have WBC mostly elsewhere, but which volume should I add under Accordance?

I was thinking perhaps a volume by a Catholic or an Anglican. Roland Murphy and John Nolland are two such authors, are there more?

 

I have for example the two Hebrews volumes both in print and under Accordance, and the Romans (by Dunn) volumes in print.

 

Is it wortwhile to get the remaining Lk volume by Nolland (the last of the three volumes) which I otherwise only have under a software which is not by far as advanced and under which I don't have BDAG?

 

I would seriously consider also volumes by authors from other denominations if those volumes have some special merits.

 

Which books of the Bible do You suggest that it's particularly important to cover? And another question: For which books of the Bible has there been significant development in scholarship very recently?


I'm growing only my Accordance and print libraries. I also occasionally duplicate things, depending on price. I don't buy Collections/base-packages at all, to me an OK print library is a Collection/base-package and is bragging-rights, a mid-size Collection would not be!! Books copyrighted in the most recent Years (2010 and later) have to be truly exceptional for me to buy them. I very rarely have to add any lexicons or Bible Dictionaries, I access them wherever, under Accordance I have bought HALOT and BDAG used. Otherwise I prefer BAGD actually which I have under L6.9. The best One-volume Bible commentary is Oxford Bible commentary, of which I have two electronic copies, one of them with full L6 functionality including Chineze (which I don't speak/read), the other one under a pretty large current account that is one I actually use. /Oct. 16. 2017 My current comparison March 20.-21. 2017 of two laptops: https://community.lo...520.aspx#891520 ... and compared to a laptop I used to have recently, things like speed and battery life
yesterday was 2 years since I returned from an archaeological trip to Turkey. /Apr 16. 2016 A bit of interest in Akkadian or Babylonian. /Apr. 2016
Besides my Macbook referenced below I have a few Windows, among the toughest I have are: 4GB W7 i3 3110 3rd gen Ivy Bridge (since it's W7 Professional and huge battery that actually can be gripped while carrying it open) | Until recently I had: 8GB W10 AMD FX-7600P (since it's AMD:s best laptop CPU - I LOVE AMD) it had the slightly overkill AMD R7 270DX 2GB graphics, i was bought new on Oct. 30. (tomorrow from 
Örebro by train) 2015 returned item so lower bargain price not on a sale. My desktop has the excellent value for money G2030 CPU Ivy Bridge
Facebook: https://www.facebook...100009160762403 (see also my Twitter).
Was on a vacation in Germany by car July 21. - Aug. 1. 2014 relaxing, evangelizing a little, while studying.
Going to teach myself the asq -programming language years later on. /June 16.-Oct 10. 2015-Apr. 16. 2016
This one is waiting for yet another motherboard change and I'm not sure it will get done IF everything continues the same: OS X 10.11 El Capitan on my 2007 Macbook Pro, with motherboard changed when it was 4 years old, disks changed as well: main drive 256 GB SSD, two new batteries. The 6 GB RAM and the two USB 3.0 ports for it (the latter through ExpressCard slot) just arrived this afternoon. /June 17. 2015


#2 Daniel Francis

Daniel Francis

    Platinum

  • Active Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,634 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Alberta, Canada
  • Interests:Contemplative prayer, ecological stewardship, science-fiction, and cat herding are some of my interests.
  • Accordance Version:12.x
  • Platforms:Mac OS X, iOS

Posted 21 November 2017 - 02:57 PM

Volume 10: 1 Samuel

 
Volume 14: 1 Chronicles
are both done by lutherans.....
 
 David J.A. Clines  I wasn't able to determine his affiliation but his work on Job was wonderful.
 
John E. Goldingay is of course an Anglican Priest.
 
-da

Edited by Daniel Francis, 21 November 2017 - 02:58 PM.


#3 Unix

Unix

    Gold

  • Active Members
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 205 posts
  • Twitter:mcyklist
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:inter/multidisciplinary humanities
  • Interests:Hebrew, "Gnosticism", Anglican books, (Environmental and a bit of Ethnological) History as well as that I've recently renewed interest in Architectual History and more modern Cultural History /Aug. 2. 2017, particular interest in texts copyrighted 1952-2010, Autumn '16 Greek. christianforums.com, unorthodoxchristian.freeforums.net Purchased Scrivener as both Win and Mac versions early June and a used Macbook Pro June 13., HDDRegenerator.net on July 17. 2015. Yet to install my Accordance version upgrade to 12 , I've been satisfied with the availability of modules in the v.10 resource format - I have just one maintained version 10 installation - it's on the i3 quad core Dell laptop. /Aug. 2. 2017
  • Accordance Version:10.x
  • Platforms:Windows

Posted 21 November 2017 - 03:52 PM

I have 1 Chron as printed matter. I've actually been considering 1 Sam under Accordance

On second thought (now that I just made a phone call to FL to check on a matter) I could stretch to buying a two-volume set (I had forgot many of the WBC-volumes are bundled like that) or perhaps two individual volumes.

But the WBC Job set is too big, I can neither ever afford it nor comprehend it, so far I've been satisfied with the Anchor -volume from the '60s which I also have in print besides here, and I've newly aquired OTL.

Btw I of course have both HALOT and BDAG bought used as individual volumes, in one go together with a few other books Years ago in a swap where I got rid of some FL books.

The Ecclesiastes volume by Murphy is cheap, does it have an amount of nontransliterated original languages so that it would be a good fit to have under Accordance?

How good is the Ruth and Esther -volume by Bush? Is it on the very technical side? Closer to two decades elapsed without that I read Esther, so I read it recently in the 1750 Douai translation. Would the WBC volume perhaps be overkill?

On third though, instead of getting two volumes under Aoccordance right now, would it be better for me to pre-order the print Edition of the new Numbers 2nd Edition by Frank Gorman which is scheduled to be release on Nov. 30. and in Edition to that get just one Accordance volume this evening?: https://www.bookdepo...96904467&sr=1-1
Someone I know whom I've just started talking with a little, likes Craig A. Evans, so it might be worthwhile getting the volume on Mk 8:27-16:20 - the volume would complement what I have but I wonder if it's too similar to the NIGTC -volume by R. T. France (I have that latter set under both Accordance and WS but not any print volumes from it):

Volume 10: 1 Samuel

 
Volume 14: 1 Chronicles
are both done by lutherans.....
 
 David J.A. Clines  I wasn't able to determine his affiliation but his work on Job was wonderful

 



#4 Ιακοβ

Ιακοβ

    Platinum

  • Active Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 559 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Australia
  • Interests:Studying MDiv. Greek. Hebrew.
  • Accordance Version:11.x
  • Platforms:Mac OS X, iOS

Posted 21 November 2017 - 05:06 PM

Regarding your suggestion that you would prefer a commentary from an author of a particular denomination, I would like to take a minute to challenge that idea just a little bit.

 

Personally, I feel a commentary is better when it exposes you all of the different points of view regarding a book, chapter, verse, and then fairly assesses the various viewpoints. When an author is just espousing what you already believe, all that is occurring is an affirmation of what you already believe. When an author is writing something you disagree with it forces you to really think about an issue and to dig deeper.  

 

What do you think?



#5 Unix

Unix

    Gold

  • Active Members
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 205 posts
  • Twitter:mcyklist
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:inter/multidisciplinary humanities
  • Interests:Hebrew, "Gnosticism", Anglican books, (Environmental and a bit of Ethnological) History as well as that I've recently renewed interest in Architectual History and more modern Cultural History /Aug. 2. 2017, particular interest in texts copyrighted 1952-2010, Autumn '16 Greek. christianforums.com, unorthodoxchristian.freeforums.net Purchased Scrivener as both Win and Mac versions early June and a used Macbook Pro June 13., HDDRegenerator.net on July 17. 2015. Yet to install my Accordance version upgrade to 12 , I've been satisfied with the availability of modules in the v.10 resource format - I have just one maintained version 10 installation - it's on the i3 quad core Dell laptop. /Aug. 2. 2017
  • Accordance Version:10.x
  • Platforms:Windows

Posted 21 November 2017 - 05:36 PM

I have a fair amount of commentaries by authors I disagree with, both because I've gone through some conversions, and because some came with FL base-packages and many with full sets. One of the recent purchases I made was the 1 Cor commentary by Fee who is a Pentecostal, Under Accordance, 2014 Edition. Also yesterday I bought seven volumes from the Complete Biblical Library -series in print, mint shape: Genesis, Matthew, Mark, Gospel of John, Acts, Romans-Corinthians, Galatians-Philemon - I haven't checked from which denomination each author comes but I suspect most are neither Catholic nor Anglican. (I have that entire set since before under WS but not currently installed on any computer).
Additionally I have the entire Exegetical Summaries -series (I only have a few volumes under FL's platforms), only one of the volumes I have also in print. A couple of sets I've been happy to purchase almost in their entirety even though they contain some volumes by authors I disagree with either because of the denomination they belonged to or that they are too liberal (or too conservative) or something else: AYBC/AYBRL and OTL/NTL. I even have some:print volumes from these series that are not offered under Accordance, and I very accurately predicted some OTL and NTL volumes to never be produced digitally under any platform and started ordering in print before Accordance even released anything:

Regarding your suggestion that you would prefer a commentary from an author of a particular denomination, I would like to take a minute to challenge that idea just a little bit.

 

Personally, I feel a commentary is better when it exposes you all of the different points of view regarding a book, chapter, verse, and then fairly assesses the various viewpoints. When an author is just espousing what you already believe, all that is occurring is an affirmation of what you already believe. When an author is writing something you disagree with it forces you to really think about an issue and to dig deeper.  

 

What do you think?

 


  • Ιακοβ likes this

#6 Ιακοβ

Ιακοβ

    Platinum

  • Active Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 559 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Australia
  • Interests:Studying MDiv. Greek. Hebrew.
  • Accordance Version:11.x
  • Platforms:Mac OS X, iOS

Posted 21 November 2017 - 05:48 PM

I find Fee's writings on Paul very helpful, especially his "God's Empowering Presence" (Thats basically a compilation of all of his commentary notes) as he provides a scholarly level of engagement representing pentecostal views. And its clear he is not denominationally biassed, as he doesn't appear to hesitate to disagree with Pentecostal views, even a few that would technically disqualify you from being a card holding AOG minister (which I believe he continued to hold through his career).


  • Unix likes this




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users